Friday, February 5, 2010

Who Do I Think I Am?

This morning, after reading the exquisitely-written Open Letter to Dr. Henry Louis Gates, Jr., posted by my friend, Luckie Daniels of Our Georgia Roots, I found myself responding with a comment on her blog that ended up sounding more like a post in itself, so I've decided to copy my response to my own blog.
The topic here was the new show, Who Do You Think You Are?, which will be airing on NBC, beginning on March 5th.  The show will feature "the quest to discover the roots" of seven celebrities.  I strongly believe that, although the intentions of the network (an extension of the original program aired in Canada via the BBC) are good; they, and other shows, like the African-American Lives series, by the well-respected and honorable Dr. Henry Louis Gates, miss a veritable opportunity by not opening their programs up to feature "regular" American researchers, who are working so hard to discover our often elusive roots.  So, in response to Luckie's letter to Dr. Gates, I offer these additional comments:

Luckie,

I just HAVE to take a few moments away from my vacation in paradise to comment on this letter! We are certainly two of a kind, for I must admit that just a few hours ago, I started to type out a “tweet” in response to the “WDYTYA Veiwing Party” concept, asking, “Am I the only one who is NOT excited about this show?”
It’s not that I don’t like the concept of the program, but ever since it was announced, I’ve felt a twinge of angst because I watch these shows when they air, and see the work that so many of us put decades of our lives into being done in a matter of a few hours or days by professional genealogists for “famous” people who have to do nothing but sit back and receive the gift of their ancestry. I’m always left feeling a bit insulted because this is how many outsiders to family history research are being introduced to it. It’s made to look too easy, too quick, and much too profitable (in terms of the payout of finding documentation) than what the reality is, especially for most African-American descendants of slaves. I had already planned to write to someone (I just wasn’t sure who) to propose that, rather than just featuring celebrities, that perhaps one of the networks might decide to “gift” some of the hard-working, dedicated, “regular” folk who are out here researching our roots. We are doing so while holding down full-time jobs, raising families, caring for elderly parents, and scrimping together funds to support the passion that takes over us to learn what we can of our history. Many times, we are using our personal leave from work to take expensive research trips, spending days and days in libraries, courthouse basements, deeds offices, and cemeteries; and having to stay in hotels, eat out (if we stop to eat) and pay for travel to and from our ancestral locations. I believe that just as much (or perhaps even more) interest could be gleaned in a program that reaches out to help the average researcher (think Extreme Makeover – Family History Edition!), as there is for the programs featuring celebrities. Certainly, those of us who’ve put in the research-equity would have an even greater appreciation and emotional response (great for TV) to being gifted with the work a professional researcher and perhaps an all-expense paid trip through time to the ancestral homes of our ancestors.
I guess since this has turned out to be more than just a quick comment, perhap we might call it, “Another open letter to whomever might be listening”

Just something to think about….


Who do I think I am? First and formost, I am a child of God! I am a descendant of slaves and slave-owners, of free blacks, and Native Americans. I hail from hard-working, self-preserving people who deserve to be discovered and have their stories told! I am a mother, an aunt, a cousin, a friend. I've been designated by my ancestors to disover and tell their stories. In essence, I am my family GRIOT, and I will continue to seek my family's history until every brick wall is smashed down and the stories within them are told.

Renate
www.tribalpages.com/tribes/nadasue

(PS... I'm writing this on the first morning of my vacation in Hawaii, thus the reference to my "vacation in paradise".)

11 comments:

Mavis said...

Renate, Thanks for voicing what a lot of us are feeling. I remember the first time I saw African Amerian Lives and being very exicted but I was also very disappointed in that the steps along the path were not shown.

Mary said...

Thanks for the nice comment you wrote on my blog and you have great energy and passion. I would love to see WDITIA do a regular person also.

DianaR said...

I love that - "Extreme Makeover – Family History Edition!" Now that is a show I could get excited about!

I agree with what you and Luckie are saying - but I know I'll still be watching both programs. It's a little bit of fantasy - wouldn't it be nice if it were that easy?!?! Sort of like the way I watch HGTV and the $100,000 makeover of JUST THE KITCHEN. Not in my world - but still fun to watch.

Herstoryan said...

Renate, thank you for commenting on my blog post! I replied, come see ...

:) Nice to meet you! I look forward to following you!

http://herstoryan.blogspot.com/2010/02/sngf-super-bowl-of-genealogy.html

grace said...

wonderful post and thank you for stopping by my blog grace

Herstoryan said...

PS. Ooooo, I am going to LOVE following you! Your skillful use of words is breathtaking! "Extreme Makeover - Family History Edition" & "Certainly, those of us who’ve put in the research-equity would have an even greater appreciation and emotional response (great for TV) to being gifted with the work a professional researcher " -- awesome! Hope you have a wonderful trip! :)

Renate said...

Wow...HerStoryan, you've got me blushing (lol)! Thank you for the compliment! I'm glad to have you as a new reader. I believe we have lots of genea-friends in common! :)
DianaR and Mary, I hope you'll keep coming back, also. Mav - thanks for always being so supportive. Hopefully, something good will come out of the "virtual" letters being posted.

Thanks for reading everyone! It does my heart glad!

Renate

Heather Rojo said...

Hi Renate, Barbara at "Life at the Roots" recommended your blog to me. She said you are in Hawaii, and I've been blogging a bit about a branch of my family tree in Hawaii. But, WOW, I love your letter to Prof. Gates! I was at NEHGS the day they were filming/photographing him there for his show. I wish I had your letter to read to him! I agree so much, and I wanted him to feature ME (a regular person on the street) on the show!

Renate said...

Hi there, Heather. Welcome to my blog! It's great to know I have a new reader.
I wish I'd heard from you a day or two earlier, because I would have been happy to have gone to look for any records you may have needed. Sadly, :(, I'm flying out in about 4 hours, but if/when I come back this way, I'll be sure to let you know! Please continue to follow my blog, and thanks so much for commenting! :)

Renate

Renate said...

Oh, and thanks to Barbara for pointing Heather to my blog!

Heather Rojo said...

I'm lucky enough to be going to Hawaii myself this summer. Perhaps by seredipity you visited some of the places I blogged about? Maybe you can fill me in on tips?